Opinion / Liu Shinan
Local officials stupidly ban solar energy
By Liu Shinan (China Daily)
Updated: 2007-01-17 07:32
The People's Daily carried a letter yesterday from a few citizens of
Yexian County, Henan Province, complaining about the county government's
banning solar powered water heaters in their community - a residential
area called Xinxin Garden.
Local officials told the newspaper's reporter that the ban was enforced
out of concern that the heaters on the roofs of the buildings "will
damage the overall beauty of Xinxin Garden", which, the government notice
said, "has become a bright spot in the new urban district".
Honestly I must say I am appalled by the stupidity demonstrated by these
officials in making such decisions and remarks. What kind of aesthetic
values did they use in ruling against the use of environmentally friendly
solar energy? Do they have any sense about respecting citizens' legal
rights?
I don't believe these officials are so ignorant that they do not know
that solar energy is the cleanest source of energy. And it is not
difficult for them to deduce that using solar energy can save the air
from being polluted and thus contribute to the beauty of the environment.
The only explanation for their way of thinking is that improved air
quality is not immediately visible in the locality while the buildings'
unified look is immediately seen.
This way of thinking might be understandable if it were held by an
individual homeowner in the estate. But it is unacceptable for officials
at the county level to think this way, since they should have more
understanding of the importance of environmental protection.
Even from a conventional aesthetic point of view, the solar heating
device is not at all repulsive. I do not know what the devices in Xinxin
Garden look like but none of the solar heaters I have seen in the market
appear awkward. And I believe anyone who enjoys a clean source of energy
will regard them as beautiful.
Banning citizens from using solar heaters is an out-and-out violation of
their civil rights. Who gives the Yexian government the power to deprive
its citizens of their right to enjoy solar energy?
The local officials explained that "the uneven silhouette of the heaters
on the roofs would harm the image of our county. Individuals' interests
should be subordinated to the overall interests of the county."
It is generally right that individuals should subordinate their own
interests to that of society if there is severe harm to the public
interest. But the Yexian case is different. The heaters did not
constitute any harm to the local environment.
Even if we take the Yexian officials' argument as correct, they would not
be able to give a convincing answer to this question: What if the matter
takes into consideration the relationship between local interests and
national interests?
The national Law on Renewable Sources of Energy stipulates that "the
State encourages organizations and individuals to install and use solar
heating devices." Isn't the Yexian County's ban a violation of the
national law? Shouldn't the "county's overall interests" be subordinated
to the national interests?
In fact, what the Yexian officials treasured was not the county's
"overall interests" but the county's "image", a euphemism for their
personal concerns over political performance.
What I discussed here is not a rare case. It represents the mentality of
a fairly large number, if not a majority, of local officials. Reports of
similar cases abound. Officials at the county level need to acquire a
better understanding of rule by law, and maybe some knowledge about
aesthetics.
Email: liushinan@chinadaily.com.cn
(China Daily 01/17/2007 page10)
Hot Talks
� Are Asian central banks using RMB as reserves now?
� President of Iraq Murdered - warning to China!
� How to be ready for a foreign boss
� Take action against the thief on the bus
� "changing china" political discussion
Most Commented/Read Stories in 48 Hours
Learn Mandarin online
No comments:
Post a Comment