Opinion / Raymond Zhou
It takes time to change mindsets
By Raymond Zhou (China Daily)
Updated: 2007-06-23 07:12
On a recent day, when a reporter dropped in on an office in North China's
Shanxi Province, he found a group of people playing cards. It was during
office hours.
This was not just any office, but the disciplinary committee of Hongdong
County. Hongdong, if you have a one-week-long memory, is the epicenter of
the scandal that shocked and shook the nation with its illegal kilns that
enslaved mentally handicapped and under-age workers and treated them with
unspeakable cruelty. It is the target of a campaign directed from the
central government to free every slave and bring those responsible to
justice.
In other words, this is probably not the best time for Hongdong officials
to wind down and have a little fun. But of course they can justify it:
they had been working overtime for the previous two days and needed a
little rest.
Who can begrudge them some freedom from the sudden overload of
outsider-induced drudgery? If they were fed only a few steamed buns and
water a day, they'd be like the child laborers and want to run away. In
an ironic similarity, one of the officials did escape from the window
when the reporter guarded the door with a slew of questions.
Compared with the enormity of the kiln story, inopportune card-playing is
just a minor act of insensitivity, hardly a sin among certain people.
Unlike most people whose indignation was raised another notch upon
hearing this incident, I have been trying to make light of it. Think of
it as stoicism in the face of unwanted media avalanche. To these people,
life must go on. What's the point of putting on a sad face for the
outside world when you can be yourself?
Between genuine numbness and hypocrisy, I may indeed prefer the former.
That gives me less false hope. Whatever you may accuse them, these people
are not guilty of fake compassion.
I bet as they learn the ways of the world they'll pick up all those
tricks, and eventually, nobody, not even they themselves, will be able to
tell whether they really feel your pain or are just play-acting. They may
call it discomfort and we may call it progress.
Sometimes the most dramatic incrimination comes from those incriminated.
But it took me a while to reconcile with the comically enlarged evidence.
Outside a big bank in San Francisco, there is a black sculpture shaped
like a heart. One day, a friend told me it represents the heart of a
banker.
This line of reasoning opened my eyes to a new way of interpreting
unhappy sights. When a television news host is repeatedly awarded, many
audience members are pissed off because he always wears a smirk on his
face. But you know what? This could be what his boss wants him to convey
to his audience. Now I see him as very real while those with forced
smiles give me goose-bumps.
It doesn't take a psychoanalyst to know that the subconscious seeps out
from layers of pomp and protocol. Several county-level governments have
built mansions that are not so faint reminders of the Tian'anmen Rostrum.
It's not far fetched to interpret that they want to be emperors in their
jurisdiction. If they had a choice, they would don the traditional garb
and throw death warrants down to the floor as in those period dramas.
Efforts to bring governance up to par with our modern society are
necessary and should be done on a systematic level. But for many local
officials, it takes longer to change the mindset that they are not put in
a place to thunder out proclamations a la Moses, but to serve the people
even when you want a moment of relaxation.
Email: raymondzhou@chinadaily.com.cn
(China Daily 06/23/2007 page4)
Hot Talks
� What is the real solution to America's trade deficit?
� What is the image of china in foreigners' eyes?
� China Got Train Technology From Foreigners
� China is in urgent need of aircraft carriers
� Rematches, returns on tap in NBA playoffs
Most Commented/Read Stories in 48 Hours
Learn Mandarin online
No comments:
Post a Comment